Tunes Tuesday – Pop Music Snobbery


I am going to admit something that will be of no surprise to anyone who has known me since high school or college – I am a musical snob. An elitist. Opinionated and condescending and with little time or patience for ‘generic pop trash’ that is foisted on the public by an industry obsessed with making money by manipulating purchases rather than providing quality product. Yikes … did I just say that out loud?

For me music is something I take seriously … think about drinking good coffee, then having a cup of instant coffee; or drinking really good wine then going back to screw-top Riunite or something like that. It isn’t that I inherently dislike pop music – it is that I find most pop music ‘harmonically unsatisfying’ … like comparing your favorite dinner to, well, something like cotton candy.

Here are what I see as my three main roadblocks to enjoying pop music:
– I consider music an entirely audio medium, so anything that is related to visuals (music videos, stage shows, dancing, or an artist’s appearance) is totally lost on me and I consider it inconsequential.
– I don’t care about lyrics. That doesn’t mean I don’t know the words to thousands of songs, just that I really don’t care. I won’t listen to music I don’t like because of lyrics, nor will I turn off music I do like due to the lyrics.
– I need some ‘meat’ to my music. Great pop songs – ‘I Will Always Love You’ popularized by Whitney Houston, ‘Time After Time’ by Cindy Lauper, ‘Borderline’ or ‘Vogue’ by Madonna, tons of Prince stuff, etc – all have more than just a ‘catchy tune’. They are well constructed songs that stand out across the decades. Most pop .. doesn’t – I remember first seeing the ‘California Gurls / Tik Tok’ mashup showing they were essentially the same song (same team wrote them, no surprise), and then more and more and more.

But the reality is that even within the pop music world there is some absolutely incredible music that is made … though honestly when it comes to songs that hit the ‘top of the pops these days’ there is precious little quality or creativity. Which is sad, really – because I know the talent is out there, it just isn’t getting heard.

Going back through the decades it is fairly easy to pluck out top selling songs that are incredibly artistic and inventive and original. I decided to only pick from the pre-sample and pre-auto-tune era, as a simple dividing point (meaning pre-1990). So I decided to do a ‘Top 20’ … but then realized I had 23 so I threaded the rest in with others. Oh well. Enjoy!

1. Bee Gees – How Can You Mend a Broken Heart

The Bee Gees are forever tied to the disco era and therefore dismissed … but they had a bunch of huge hits before Saturday Night Fever, and this song is just amazing. Deep and complex and with a tremendous sense of building urgency.

2. Joni Mitchell – Hejira

Joni Mitchell transitioned from writing songs for others to becoming a master folk singer to a pop star and then … this. She kept progressing musically with alternate tuning structures, using her voice as if it was a jazz saxophone. Yet it remains beautiful and haunting.

3. Stevie Wonder – Overjoyed

Sure I could have plucked from Stevie’s ‘golden era’, songs like ‘I Wish’, ‘Higher Ground’ and so on, but this classic from a decade later reminds us WHY he is more than just a pop star, he is a pure musical genius.

Jazz saxophonist Richie Cole did a great cover version, but the CD is out of print and never was released digitally (I have way too many CDs from the mid-late 80s like that!)

4. Dionne Warwick – Say a Little Prayer

You would never guess that the verse is in 10/4 time and the chorus in 11/4 time, very complex meters for such an accessible song.

Blind Avant-garde multi-saxophonist Roland Kirk did a cover a year later that brought in the civil rights aspects … seriously, check this one out:

5. Elton John – Goodbye Yellow Brick Road

Elton John and Stevie Wonder are two of the main reason pop and rock was incredible in the 70s. This isn’t just stuff to listen to and sing, it merits actual study:

And “Don’t Let the Sun Go Down on Me”.

6. Neil Diamond – I Am, I Said

Like Joni Mitchell, Neil Diamond started off writing songs for others, including “I’m a Believer” by The Monkees. Soon enough he was singing and performing his own music, like this classic anthem.

8. The Rolling Stones – Under My Thumb

While most people think of Jagger & Richards as the keys to the Stones, every major melody that was a hit in the early years was composed by Brian Jones – including this jazzy syncopated tune with vibes added to the mix.

9. The Cars – Drive

I like the anthemic feel that was their sort of swan song, but it also embodies the modal harmonies from Miles Davis ‘Kind of Blue’.

10. The Police – Darkness

The Police were masters of expanded harmonies, advanced rhythms and other things you simply don’t get in pop music. This is my favorite song of theirs, as there are multiple rhythms playing against each other.

11. The Beatles – Tomorrow Never Knows

Picking a great Beatles song is easy, so I wanted to do something less well known but that shows off their musical creativity and also their studio wizardry.

12. The Yardbirds – Shapes of Things

The same year as the last song, The Yardbirds were advancing ‘hard rock’ in a way that was melodic yet in-your-face. Jeff Beck’s early solo albums would introduce heavy metal before Led Zepplin and others arrived.

13. Mary Ford & Les Paul – How High the Moon

Going back to the #1 song of 1951, this is a reminder of how pop songs were always pop – but at one time there was a genuine requirement to be able to sing and play instruments.

14. Simon & Garfunkel – Scarborough Fair / Canticle

Not an original melody, but shows an amazing example of taking an centuries-old classic and reworking it for the modern era!

15. Bridge over troubled Water

Paul Simon has an incredible library of deceptively complex songs that are memorable and instantly recognizable. With an over-the-top dense production and wearing its heart on its sleeve, this remains an iconic piece of pop art nearly 45 years after release.

16. Marvin Gaye – What’s Going On

Marvin Gaye was an incredible vocalist, and this song just rips at your heart and soul … and much of that has to do with the movement within the harmonic structure. A good song can ‘play you’ emotionally even without words, and that is what happens here – the vocals just add even more pull.

17. Blondie – Rapture

The first bit hit for rap, and the first one to get any play on MTV … and just an insanely catchy song that remains interesting and worth listening to while thousands of other rap songs fall to the wayside.

18. Michael Jackson – Thriller

The reason Thriller works so well (the album as well as the song) has to do with the full orchestration of Quincy Jones as much as the great songs themselves. These are essentially big band songs for the modern day, with pop instrumentation supplanting horn sections. And it completely works.

19. 10cc – I’m Not In Love

It is hard to hear this song and not feel like you are floating on air; like so many on this list, this song brings me back … this one to AM radio and getting ready for school in he 70s.

Also check out this Buzzfeed post about the making of the song.

20. Steely Dan – Peg

Aside from writing great songs, Steely Dan enlisted some of the greatest studio musicians and perfectly crafted their sound while having others playing the instruments. The results were always interesting.

There are many more I could have chosen – I didn’t touch Queen or the people I mentioned before like Madonna or Prince. There is an incredible library of popular music out there – I just got and am listening to an upcoming release by the jazz group ‘Thrasher Dream Trio’ of popular R&B songs such as ‘Where is the love’ and others.

So what are some of your favorite ‘not musically trivial’ pop songs? Or do you just hate me now?

18 thoughts on “Tunes Tuesday – Pop Music Snobbery

  1. Hahaha, oh my. I can absolutely understand being musically opinionated, I’m just not. I have a very eclectic taste in music, and I’m generally pretty easy to please. Although, I will say that a lot of pop music lately has followed an annoying trend of “sampling” from great songs or doing covers of originals, which, to me, is akin to the trend in Hollywood of remaking classics and “rebooting” popular series. I feel like a lot of the originality is gone, which is sad.

    Also, unlike you, I do pay a LOT of attention to lyrics, and if a song is saying something that I don’t like (Blurred Lines, anyone?), I WON’T listen to it. Of course, Robin Thicke also stole Marvin Gaye’s beat, but that’s another story.

    • Thanks Rae!

      I totally agree on the ‘reductive’ tendency of sampling and rebooting things (like, new Spiderman movies … again?!?).

      And when someone points out the crap said in songs (like Blurred Lines) that I don’t caer about anyway … it is MORE reason not to listen. Kinda like all of Taylor Swift … passive-aggressive, indirect, non-confrontational back-stabbing BS is NOT ’empowerment’ …

  2. Oh, this is a glorious collection of some of my favorites. I grew up listening to oldies and soft rock/pop with my parents (and then pop etc as I grew older), so I definitely have an affinity for the amazing harmonies, melodies, and incredible song and story crafting that music writers used to employ. I have to say, and feel free to disagree, but it’s how I feel, that one band (and yes, it is a boy band!) that got it right was the Backstreet Boys on their Millennium album. Not ever single song, but some of the most incredible and haunting (in a good way) songs were on that album, and they were (as far as I can tell) original, though evocative.
    I totally second Rae in that I am SO OVER the sampling thing. Make your own music. Be inventive, be daring. But be real.
    And you? A music snob? NEVER πŸ˜‰

    • The Backstreet Boys are one of those groups that people (adults) would never admit to liking … my boys liked them when they were little so we have the Millenium CD, and Lisa played it at work and EVERYONE was singing along … guess the shame has passed, eh?

      Sampling can definitely have a place in a creative song-making … but NOT as a *substitute* for creative song-making! πŸ™‚

  3. Ok, don’t hate me, but I don’t mind the bad pop on the radio these days haha. I love many of the songs you mentioned here, too, but I am a top 40s girl most of the time (with a touch of alternative, especially when joe’s in charge of the radio….I love film scores and broadway musicals too πŸ˜› ). If the lyrics amuse me (or I actually like them) or the song has a good beat I can dance (in or out of my car) to or run to, it’s probably on my running playlist (which I use for everything else, too)…unless it’s by taylor swift or that “rude” song…both thoroughly irritate me and get turned in my car πŸ˜›

    • haha – I am very much alone in my snobbery! Lisa loves pop – and loads of other pop and alternative stuff. Chris is a pop-head as well, and Danny knows all the songs. They are often stunned by what I don’t know in terms of pop music …

  4. Preach it, Mike, preach! I’ve been on a neil diamond, (and subsequently buffalo springfield) and van morrison and kick lately. The pandora station I made for this mix has been doing a really good job. I’ll admit– i like a pop songs like i like cupcakes– every now and then they’re fun and sweet but not very satisfying πŸ™‚

    • I grew up with Neil Diamond (my mom was a huge fan) so I knew it all, and have always appreciated what he brought to music as a songwriter.

      I like the cupcake analogy … or maybe I’m just hungry … πŸ™‚

  5. I’m the least musical person I know, and part of that very unfortunate generation of women whose musical tastes were 100% hijacked and then derailed by New Kids (and Jordan’s dreamy eyes), which largely ruined us for all future music we’d hear.
    I sometimes listen to music (usually pop) on a solo run on a closed trail, or when I’m getting dressed for the day in the locker room at work, but in general, I don’t have much music in my life. I think I’m honestly tone deaf, no joke (and I think my Chinese teacher might agree…).

    • There is always someone – remember Shaun Cassidy? He wrecked a generation of girls πŸ™‚

      I totally get that there are people for whom music isn’t a big thing … but at the same time I can’t really conceive of it. I see words on a page and ‘hear’ them melodically …

  6. Good songs! I admit that running has changed music taste somewhat, I find I need pop-ier music to run to. My music taste is all over the place though. I don’t know most current stuff and listen to a lot of rock mostly but I do love Taylor Swift, sorry! My road trip was to the music of REO Speedwagon, Styx and Giufrria. Random right?

    • Thanks Falyn – since I don’t run with music (ever), it hasn’t impacted my listening, but I definitely get the need for music-runners to have stuff that works for that as well! As for what you listen to … that is purely a choice, right? πŸ™‚

  7. While I’m not music opinionated, I can tell the differences between music now and music from a while ago. Both to me, have their interesting qualities. I will run and workout to different music than I listen to on say a car ride. I have heard and do know all of these songs but two so I hope I get some of your approval. πŸ˜‰

    • OMG “actively dislike ” …. I LOVE IT! haha Seriously – since I listen to avant garde jazz I am used to ‘active dislike’ for THAT music, but not so much the pop.

      I would LOVE to hear more about your feelings about this … seriously! πŸ™‚ Totally love the comment.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s